| Platinum | Tomacelli's Pizza & Pasta |
| Gold | Sunny's Pizzeria |
| Silver | Bread & Circus Sandwich Kitchen |
| Bronze | Uncle Ed's Specialty Meats |
| Top Pick | Fazoli's |
| Top Pick | Firehouse Subs |
| Top Pick | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Pizza Cheeks |
| Top Pick | Remedy Brewing Company |