| Platinum | B & G Milkyway |
| Gold | CherryBerry |
| Silver | Feldy's Ice Cream |
| Bronze | Parlour Ice Cream House |
| Top Pick | Cold Stone Creamery |
| Top Pick | Culver's |
| Top Pick | El Chamoy Sioux Falls |
| Top Pick | Polar Bites / Dakota Snow |
| Top Pick | Stensland Family Farms |
| Top Pick | Sweet Cheeks |