| Platinum | Inca Mexican Restaurant |
| Gold | Plaza Azteca |
| Silver | Jacky's Restaurant & Bakery |
| Bronze | Puerto Vallarta Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Azteca |
| Top Pick | El Chamoy Sioux Falls |
| Top Pick | El Tapatio Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | La Plaza Fiesta |
| Top Pick | Mama's Ladas |
| Top Pick | Manna Bakery |